Skip to content

Reviews

529

Page 41 of 53

  1. Orcs Must Die!

    Xbox 360 · Griffin McElroy · Oct 05, 2011

    If the writing were as clever as the gameplay it supports, Orcs Must Die would be a comedy masterpiece. It oscillates perfectly between states of calm, cool and collected design and panicked damage control, and rewards your diligence with a gorgeous sight: A finely-tuned whirling chamber of death, which gnaws up enemies with tactical brutality reminiscent of Tecmo's Deception series, and a gory kind of whimsy reminiscent of Grape Escape.
    8.0
  2. Rage

    Xbox 360 · Arthur Gies · Oct 04, 2011

    RAGE is pretty at times, but it's not enough to paint over the truth - that Id's labor feels like a scaffolding for a game of bolder ideas, ideas which, for whatever reason, aren't realized. And the game that is there just isn't enough to compete with other, better shooters we've seen this year.
    6.0
  3. Dark Souls: Prepare to Die Edition

    PS3 · Richard Mitchell · Oct 03, 2011

    Still, after a while, I began to interpret these strange choices as just another facet of Dark Souls' relentless difficulty. After a few hours – about fifteen in my case – things begin to gel and the walls of Dark Souls start to crumble, revealing the delectable treats within.
    9.0
  4. FIFA Soccer 12

    Xbox 360 · Mike Suszek · Sep 30, 2011

    The best additions this year are bits of the unexpected, something almost never achieved in sports video games. FIFA 12 delivers enough of those flashes of brilliance to feel a little less like a game, and more like a true soccer simulator.
    9.0
  5. X-Men: Destiny

    Xbox 360 · Justin McElroy · Sep 28, 2011

    In years past, Silicon Knights boss Denis Dyack has railed against critics writing "previews" that feel more like reviews of what's still a half-finished product. How ironic that his company and Activision have just forced me to do exactly that
    3.0
  6. Renegade Ops

    Xbox 360 · Ludwig Kietzmann · Sep 20, 2011

    Renegade Ops is adequate for what it attempts to be, but it's more conformist than the title suggests. Even the game's mission objectives struggle to summon interesting tasks after a while, resulting in the staunch General Bryant asking you to collect artifacts which he has determined belong in a museum.
    6.0
  7. Gears of War 3

    Xbox 360 · Arthur Gies · Sep 15, 2011

    Gears of War 3 has left me with a parallel set of emotions. On one side, it represents a powerful elegy, a close to a series that has done much to define this console generation. It's a melancholy thing, seeing a solid conclusion for characters that a lot of us liked despite ourselves, that make themselves even more understood in the end.
    10
  8. Dead Island

    Xbox 360 · Justin McElroy · Sep 15, 2011

    There's so much content in Dead Island, it's a real shame the work wasn't done to take it from functional to fun. Some of it works: There's a beautiful world to explore here, some genuinely neat ideas and cool weapons. But the end product too closely mirrors its antagonists: Shambling forward, but only just.
    6.0
  9. Tropico 4

    PC · Alexander Sliwinski · Sep 07, 2011

    It's not a sequel that's trying to change the game, it's just trying to make sense of all that extra stuff in Tropico 3 that had very little explanation. The pacing and presentation of objectives is what's really different: They make Tropico 4 feel fresh, despite the truly remarkable ripeness of the franchise's core mechanics.
    8.0
  10. Disgaea 4: A Promise Unforgotten

    PS3 · Jason Dobson · Sep 07, 2011

    As another worthwhile and entertaining entry in the franchise, Disgaea 4 is still just another Disgaea game. Fans will love it for everything it is, while detractors will ignore it for all that it isn't. This is a game, and series, that isn't out to win over gamers by changing its stripes -- though its fans probably wouldn't have it any other way.
    8.0