Xbox One

Madden NFL 25

11 critics

Score Distribution

9.00 to 10.0
8.00 to 8.99
6.00 to 7.99
4.00 to 5.99
0 to 3.99
Matthew KatoNov 19, 2013
These latter two points may be relatively insignificant, but the franchise mode still hasn't recovered all of the features that were previously purged, and presents limited choices such as not being able to negotiate rookie or in-season free agent contracts. ...Madden's next-gen debut is certainly better than when the series first appeared for the last generation, but there's still plenty of work to be done.
Bobby AmosNov 15, 2013
Madden games catch a lot of flack for not changing enough every year, but here’s an example of why change isn’t always a good thing. ...But this new version of Madden 25 meddles with the running game and it screws up the delicate balance between pass and run. Once EA manages to combine all this lifelike ambience and smarter players with responsive control of current-gen Madden, I’ll be a lot happier with the new generation.
Trevor HoustonNov 24, 2013
Not to mention those painfully long load times and other glitches that continue to plague the game on the Xbox 360 are gone. If you own Madden 25 on current generation systems, you could wait until next year but that could also be a mistake as Madden 25 on the Xbox One feels like a considerable leap over the current generation game. It may be the biggest leap we have seen in the franchise yet.
Alex NavarroNov 22, 2013
On that note, you're probably just fine waiting for next year to make the generational leap with this franchise. Unless you've held out this long on buying Madden 25 on any platform, and really, really just want a new--albeit middling--game of football to play for the next few months, Madden NFL 25 doesn't represent enough of a leap forward to make it either a technical showpiece for your new console, nor a more exciting football game than what EA already put out a few months ago.
Brett PhippsAug 28, 2014
Madden NFL 15 is an excellent return to form for the series. Yes, it’s still plagued by legacy issues, but the leaps taken on defence, coupled with the spiffy new graphics and excellent gameplay, make this an essential purchase for longstanding fans and a great starting point for players looking to jump on board.
Miguel ConcepcionNov 26, 2013
As part of the launch lineups of both of this year's new consoles, Madden NFL 25 is a fine entry that relies on the foundation of the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions with a few meaningful improvements. ...Madden 25 lands on the positive end of the quality spectrum, and it's satisfying enough to warrant weekly sessions well beyond Super Bowl XLVIII.
Andrew ToddDec 12, 2013
Confusing to newcomers. Microtransactions are crass. More geared towards fantasy football management than actual gameplay. Defense plays itself. Snickers Really Satisfies™, repeatedly, in every game. A superb and detailed imitation of TV football, an occasionally exciting gameplay experience, and what can feel like an exercise in monetisation from EA.
Mathias OertelNov 13, 2013
Unter dem Strich ist das von Ignite angetriebene Madden NFL 25 ein typischer Übergangstitel von der einen zur anderen System-Generation: Es ist ein von Kinderkrankheiten geplagter Schritt in die richtige Richtung, der das Potenzial andeutet, zu dem sich die Serie wieder aufschwingen kann.
LespolDec 04, 2013
Malgré les apparences, Madden NFL 25 n'est qu'un épisode parmi d'autres et ne célèbre en rien l'anniversaire de la franchise. Pire, il se montre assez pauvre en termes de nouveautés et affiche des graphismes pas vraiment next-gen. ...Les joueurs qui souhaiteraient découvrir la série ou le foot US peuvent donc se laisser tenter sans risque.
Marco SalvaneschiJan 18, 2014
Raramente il primo vero touchdown di una serie sportiva su un nuovo campo di gioco avviene al debutto. Anche nel caso in oggetto, il passaggio alla “next gen” tentato da Madden NFL 25 risulta incompleto, malgrado non possa certo essere considerato un disastroso fumble e nemmeno un brutto intercetto. ...Che in un gioco di football americano su Xbox One ci starebbe peraltro come il cacio sul maccarone. What's american boy!
Luca ForteDec 20, 2013
Dal prodotto pensato per festeggiare il venticinquesimo anniversario della serie ci saremmo aspettati qualcosina di più, ma come tutti i giochi di prima generazione anche Madden NFL 25 ha pagato l'inesperienza del team di sviluppo con i nuovi hardware e il poco tempo a loro disposizione rinunciando a proporre qualcosa di nuovo. La sensazione è infatti quella di trovarsi di fronte a poco più che un copia/incolla della struttura classica.