It has its positives and negatives. On the upside, it's fun and intense with a 4v4 soccer match. I love the characters; although I would like more. Boom Boom as a goalie is stupid since he is a big, wide character who is blocking the damn goal.
I would give this score higher if there were more updates, more customization, and more characters.
I'm lighter than a lot of people since an 8 feels like a great score. When reviewing a Mario title, I am downgrading it. An 8 to me, as a big Mario fan, is not an amazing score. It's meh.