I Am Dead

Critic reviews

• PLPS Lifestyle

  Rebecca Smith · Sep 06, 2021

  7.5

  I Am Dead is a hidden object game where players can get as much or as little out of it as they wish. Those following the story will find a short but simple game, perhaps too simple for some. The secondary objectives add more to do but seem like a compromise to keep adventure veterans entertained seeing as they carry very little reward. Away from the gameplay, I Am Dead dances around the raw emotions of death but deals with its impacts in a pleasant way.

  Read review from PS Lifestyle (opens in a new tab)
• CCOGconnected

  Michael Chow · Aug 24, 2021

  8.5

  Overall, I Am Dead is still the solid title it was when it was first released on the PC and Nintendo Switch. While it’s short and the gameplay loop does get repetitive, the overall narrative, aesthetics, and audio turn Shelmerston into a beautiful location. Whether it was the traditions of the island, the history of its residents, or simply the beautiful locations, Shelmerston was easily the highlight of my experience.

  Read review from COGconnected (opens in a new tab)
• WTWay Too Many Games

  Heidi Hawes · Aug 18, 2021

  6.0

  There’s absolutely no challenge in I Am Dead, aside from the easily missable riddles. I understand that some games are about the journey and not the challenge, but most of I Am Dead is a bore. If you’re looking for a casual and uplifting gaming experience about death and finding yourself, try Spiritfarer instead.

  Read review from Way Too Many Games (opens in a new tab)
• PSPush Square

  Stephen Tailby · Aug 18, 2021

  7.0

  There's also Mr. Whitstable's riddles, which add a little challenge to each level. He'll give you a set of clues, and they each pertain to a specific thing in that stage, and could be anywhere. Sometimes the clues are too obtuse, but with thorough exploration and a little lateral thinking, the riddles add some substance to a rather breezy game. Wonderful art and relaxing music make the cherry on top of a unique and heartfelt cake.

  Read review from Push Square (opens in a new tab)
• HPHey Poor Player

  Andrew Thornton · Aug 16, 2021

  6.0

  Spending time with the citizens of Shelmerston is incredibly charming and makes I Am Dead worth a look. With an unsatisfying conclusion and gameplay, which quickly grows a bit one-note, however, this won’t be a game for everyone. Still, if you want a charming little game to spend a quiet afternoon with, you could do far worse.

  Read review from Hey Poor Player (opens in a new tab)
• XXboxEra

  Bruno Costa · Aug 13, 2021

  8.0

  Its puzzles are nowhere near challenging and the exploration is limited to small areas, but they are still enjoyable thanks to the heartwarming story that unfolds after each section. When combining it all with the vivid visuals and remarkable voice work, you cannot help but feel right at home.

  Read review from XboxEra (opens in a new tab)

See all critic reviews