We played games whose stories and rich world we could live in for hours, months, and even years. Many of us craved those monumental experiences. Living thousands of lives. Conquering colossal bosses. Soaring the skies and diving into the deepest depths to save our friends.
While endings have slowly vanished from the equation, they still offer us a lot. Whether in the form of resolutions or unanswered questions.
2023 hasn't always been sunshine and rainbows, but we did witness a lot of things that made our hearts sing. What whatoplay offers for the end of this year is a celebration of all those things and the hope that more excitement is coming over the horizon.
Critics or gamers? It doesn't matter. When it comes to our 2023 Game of the Year, critics and gamers agreed to give their highest marks to…
PC, console, or mobile, we all have our little kingdoms. In 2023, we tracked all 8 modern platforms aggregating 18,056 critic reviews and 35,786,193 gamer ratings. Who ruled who? Let's find out:
Here at whatoplay, winning and losing is a numbers game. Which game had us all talking, and who made the grade?
While some games can get us in our feelings, some games do not spark joy. You let it all out and you weren't alone.
What could've been a compelling look into the storied life of an iconic Tolkien character became nothing but an exercise in tedium. Playing through the bugs, unwieldy controls, and awkward stealth mechanics was like being taken down into Gollum's own descent into madness.
Forspoken's public fate is less vitriol and more dismissive eye roll. It had great visuals but with poor optimization; and a decent open-world exploration constantly interrupted by a talkative cuff. The real crime here is how it gets in its way.
Critics might tell you Forza Motorsport's souped-up realism and racing dynamics are worth swooning over. On the other hand, long-time fans would counter that its new progression system left them fuming.
Caught amidst the ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine, GSC Gameworld's decision to delay is understandable. However, in light of the game's positive previews and this year's dearth of atmospheric shooters, we just can't help but feel a little impatient.
Not bad for a surprise launch. This flashy rhythm action had heads turning and banging to its beat. From its flashy animations to its pitch-perfect gameplay, Hi-Fi Rush hits every high note and it's here to stay.
The world fell in love with Baldur's Gate 3 and so did you! Larian Studios, with its perfect balance of story, characters, and customizations, has swept the world off its feet. Whether you're in it for the romance or the challenge, it's clear there's no other place you'd rather be.
Genres are a celebration of our diverse tastes. For our genre winners, victory sure is sweet.
Among the hundreds of worthy Indies, this meta-horror wormed its way to the top the way it wormed into our consciousness. Slay the Princess isn't a jump to action, it's an ever-present question. Every path has been carefully designed and following them rewards us with both joy and dread.
There's a daring in Tears of the Kingdom's commitment to the single-player experience. Understanding the intimacy of a player against a world of exciting challenges, it offers us the private joys of discovering all its wonderful secrets.
When it comes to high-flying action, no one does it like Spider-Man 2. Combining the powers of Miles, Peter, and Venom, the usual combat ballet gave way to harder hits and the new traversal skills made us feel as much like Spider-Man as we could ever hope.
It is a once-in-a-generation masterpiece; there has never been an RPG quite like this. Its faithfulness to tactical RPG might feel old school. But, the dense world, dizzying combat options, rich stories, and endless interactive possibilities are nothing if not ground-breaking.
Capcom ushers in an era of friendly fighting by opening up the SF arena to a new generation of fighters. With the Drive System that takes fights from 0 to 100, and a World Tour that takes you through the ropes, Street Fighter 6 is the perfect welcome basket.
Before the heartbreak of Mimimi Games' shutdown, they gave us another one of their virtuoso strategies. Their nuanced and rewarding tactical mechanics are on full display in this stealth pirate package. All of it is balanced out by its unsurprisingly gorgeous presentation.
The new chapter in the writer's block saga emerges as a runaway success. Alan Wake II is a compelling double feature. Saga's detective work and Alan's Dark Place are brimming with a blend of top-notch puzzles, intense gunplay, and spine-chilling environmental scares. From Control to this stunning sequel, Remedy has cast itself as a master of the craft.
This wordless puzzler doesn't need dialog to take you as far as you want. Step by step, it takes you on a ride—short as it may be—from one Orb world to the next. It feels just like a Cocoon: ever-evolving yet always a comfort.
This may be a 2D Mario game but it isn't short on dimension. Its levels are brimming with charm and it's only amplified by what the Wonder Flower brings to every stage. Nintendo has set a new standard for vibrance and innovation in Mario games, and this one definitely lives up to its name.
A true testament to the principle of “if it ain't broke.” Everything we loved about Octopath Traveler has been polished to perfection in this sequel. The characters are brand new and made more alive with enriched interactions and refined turn-based combat.
Simple yet refined, lightning quick. The iconic locations and Marvel collectibles may have been a huge draw, but there was no doubt that Marvel Snap's revolutionary card play always had the strength for a wider appeal.
Apple Arcade got us a ticket to this full-fledged island getaway with all our favorite Sanrio characters. Loaded with content in such a small package—from cooking and decorating to all-out adventures—every day here is loaded with fun and friendship. Hello Kitty is giving Nintendo a run for its money.
The real stars of the show: You! Your reviews and ratings made all of this possible. Here's a shout-out to our most loyal contributors:
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the KingdomJoseph SchwartzThe art, the graphics, the music. Everything is nice and clean! This is going to be the game of the year!
Star Wars Jedi: Survivorrobiu013...in my eyes the game is pretty good. It expands on the concepts it introduced in the previous games and improves the series in many ways. But it struggles with a few performance issues and graphical blemishes I've seen covered better in other games on the PS5. I am however definitely looking forward to a third game...
Demon Slayer -Kimetsu no Yaiba- The Hinokami ChroniclesCommando KittyPlaying the game is definitely another way to experience the Demon Slayer universe. As a fan, I'm looking forward to the DLCs to follow and hopefully it will fulfill the satisfying umph the game can offer like the anime it was copied from.
Super Mario 3D WorldJezreel Ian Manuel...Super Mario 3D World on Nintendo Switch is an incredible game that is a must-play for fans of the Mario franchise. Its stunning visuals, engaging sound design, responsive controls, fun mechanics, and compelling characters make it one of the best Mario games to date.
ARMORED CORE VI: FIRES OF RUBICON - Mecha! This is the perfect modern game for those of us who grew up with Gundam.
NeilCo-founder
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - Why not? Simply play and lose many hours in this larger and better game mechanics than BOTW!
JehoData Curator
Alan Wake II - The sequel we needed and it didn't disappoint! It's a spiral!
ThirdyScript Writer
Venba - This game moved me. It also made me so hungry and crave Indian food.
RaineMarketing Coordinator
Hi-Fi RUSH - Definitely the best game I've played in a while; it stands out among the rest of the Xbox collections. It's very fun and entertaining, keeping me stuck to the beat.
CristianaLead Developer / DevOps
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - The new abilities, large exploration & storyline has been a great experience overall. The game is challenging and creative.
AnalynAdmin / Lead Data Curator
Armored Core VI: Fires of Rubicon - Who doesn't want to pilot a badass robot?! This game's a masterpiece of mechanical mayhem, it redefines what mech combat can be. It's glorious!
AyadFrontend Developer
Have a Nice Death - I want to be “Death”, death to my department heads that think they own my business.
OjieData Automation Developer
Dave the Diver - Just when you think the Sushi Resto madness gets boring, it hits with wave after wave of new undersea adventures. The beauty of it is that you only need to go as deep as you want to.
PiaUX Designer
Dave the Diver - It's just the right mix of goofy, fun yet also the right amount of challenging. It's indie done right! The funny weebo “transformation” scenes took me out!
TylCreative Production Manager
Loddlenaut - Aside from being a cute game, this game is so satisfying. Cleaning up the ocean and helping the ecosystem from being polluted is so fulfilling but keep in mind that you need to make sure that you have enough oxygen to save the ocean. So, let's clean!
HazelData Curator
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - I just love how the player can build things from scrap! Plus, it's an open-world adventure! So, why not.
AmandaData Curator
2023 draws to a close and the next year is looming over us. Luckily, we see a few good gems on the horizon.